Beachfront vacation rentals in Rye Beach

Peter's property was the IDEAL HOME BASE for my exploration of western Connecticut. The home was extremely clean and tidy, mattresses were very comfortable, linens and towels were of nice quality, the kitchen was well equipped, and the yard was safe and easily accessible for my dogs. I truly felt like Peter's guest when I saw ground coffee in the cupboard, ample silverware, extra paper towels, hand soap, new kitchen sponges, and high end fragrance diffusers. After a long day of travel, it was nice to relax without having to clean the home. I was impressed by how quiet this neighborhood was considering how closely set the homes are to one another and how many year-round families live in the area. It's truly a pedestrian neighborhood with miles of sidewalks for relaxed walking. The gem is proximity to the lovely marina and beach. Peter was an excellent host! He offered many recommendations during my stay and was always quick to respond despite being on vacation himself.

Rob was very responsive to all emails and texts and all the instructions for checking in/checking out were very clear. House was exactly as advertised. Easy to get to beach and town. We had a really nice stay.

My family and I had a great time, our host were very welcoming.

We had a lovely stay at Jenna's. The apartment was spacious and very clean, as shown in the photos. Well located, minutes from the boardwalk, quiet area. We met Jenna and her husband, who were very nice. They made sure everything was going well for us and they gave us restaurant recommendations. I recommend it without hesitating!

This was perfect for our 2 night stay while in town visiting Granma for her 98th birthday! Very good location in a nice neighborhood, private easy entry, very clean, comfy bed and linens, nice hosts - we'll stay again!

Joseph is a great host and is always responsive to my request. The check-in process is super easy and the place is exactly as described in the photo and the description. The location is quite, peaceful, easy to find, and there are planety of good restaurants around that area. View as it is on an island is also pretty good! Highly recommend!

Arthur was a gracious host. He was accommodating, friendly and knowledgeable.

This is a charming house with a wonderful view. Very comfortable and has everything you may need for your stay. William was very solicitous that everything was to our satisfaction – which it was. We totally enjoyed our stay.

The place matched the description perfectly and much more spacious than what one usually finds for a single bed/bath apartment. I enjoyed the stay and would return again. For me it was a perfect place to accommodate overflow thanksgiving guests over the holiday.

very nice

Good price and clean area

Jim’s place was an absolute gem for my inaugural trip to Black Rock! The Loft is incredibly spacious and equipped with everything you could possibly need for a perfect stay. From the moment I arrived, I was impressed by the meticulous cleanliness, attention to detail, and beautiful furnishings. Jim's communication was top-notch, making the entire experience seamless. One of the highlights was the extensive music collection, perfect for setting the mood during my downtime. The bed and furniture provided a level of comfort that made it hard to leave. Nestled on a serene, tree-lined street, the location couldn’t be better; it’s just a leisurely stroll away from delightful restaurants, charming shops, food markets, and more. I can’t wait to return for another stay whenever I’m in the area!

Hidden gem!!! Shhhh don’t tell anyone this place was fabulous and I want to stay the whole summer! Nothing bets fire island and this house was the perfect retreat!!! Beautiful, spotless and well put together! Loved it! Perfect for a family or friends get away!!! Hosts were responsive and friendly as well. Close to beach and great to a have a pool for part of the day! Great location walkable/bikable to Seaview, Ocean Beach and Ocean Bay Park for dinner was a breeze! A must!

nice and clean

Thank you so much for taking us in last minute👍

I’ve rented my fair share of houses on Fire Island over the years and I can honestly say that Whitney & Anthony’s house was the nicest, by far. It looked exactly like the pictures, which showed how beautiful, modern and immaculate the space was. It had every amenity and convenience you could ask for, and it was in a perfect location… one house off the beach. Whitney & Anthony were incredibly proactive, reaching out to me several times to give me updated information and also to send me a gift in advance of our stay. They obviously know what they’re doing and how to best accommodate visitors because they had very clear instructions for everything and even some YouTube videos to show us how to convert the pool into a hot tub and other specifics. There are no better beaches to visit than that of Fire Island and our experience celebrating our twin daughter’s 16th birthday at Whitney & Anthony’s house was nothing short of magical. We will absolutely be back if they’ll have us!

Wow!!! Absolutely Amazing! This was our 1st Fall Girls Trip 17-20Nov2024 & We LOVED your home! Whoever decorated this house deserves 10 ⭐️⭐️s!! …You out did yourself!!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! Very Peaceful/Relaxing Stay💕 We hated to leave💕

Just checked out. Wanted to say how hospitable and amazing the bnb was. We have a huge family and everything was perfect. Many memories from this house now especially the Wedding memories. Also thank you for being super flexible and understanding

Angela’s place was one of the best AirBnBs I’ve ever stayed in! Absolutely beautiful surroundings and her home looks like it’s out of a magazine! In fact, I’ve already booked another week next month! Five stars ⭐️ across the board!

Beautiful place! I spent a week at Robert's place with my wife, setting up my office and laptops there. I got to watch the bay and swans floating down it while working. I got DoorDash, Amazon, and Total Wine deliveries while I stayed there and all were seamless. The location is easily found. TV was great in the den area. We watched a couple of movies on Prime. Perfect location, outside the craziness of mainland Long Island. I loved it! Would love to stay again.

A nice Cozy beach condo, its Very close to a bunch of restaurants & Bars so it made it even more convenient. Plus its a very quiet area so sleeping was no problem. Id definitely stay here again!

This house in Point Lookout was lovely. Only steps away from the beach. Provided all the extras - bikes, chairs… Dan was a great host. We’ll definitely stay again!

Our stay was great! It was the cleanest air bnb I’ve ever stayed in, hands down. Laura was amazing. I felt like she was my mom that had planned for me to come and stay. Everything from the snacks in the unit, to accommodating me with a ride to and from my classes down the street. Laura was so friendly and made sure we were taken care of. I really appreciated her attentiveness to our stay and needs. I would recommend this host and air bnb!

Beautiful and really cozy. Love how close clubs and bars are it’s perfect for a small little vaca!! Definitely coming back soon!