Cabin vacation rentals in New Buffalo

We had an absolutely wonderful stay at this cottage! Very cozy and in a great location. Would visit again!

Our stay at Jason’s cabin was a 4/5 experience. While the cabin had potential, several issues impacted our visit. The biggest problem was the misleading description: we assumed each cabin was private based on the photos, but the fine print revealed it’s actually a shared community space. We spoke with other guests, and they had the same confusion. One cabin was told the sauna was private, while others were given shared-use instructions, which felt inconsistent. The hot tub area had a red ant infestation, and I ended up with several bites. Additionally, the property has multiple hosts, leading to unclear communication. One of the other occupants even shared pictures showing how unclean their cabin was, which raised concerns about cleanliness across the property. In our cabin, the floor was coming apart, which was disappointing. Knowing all this now, I’d consider staying again if I were more inclined to being social and sharing space with others. However it wasn’t quite what I expected

The place itself was nice and updated providing us with everything we needed. We loved that it was so close to everything. And it was a bonus to have the pickleball court, firepit, and hot tub.

Very cute, updated and easy to get to. Although you are near other cabins, Jason and Jamie have made it as private as possible. They were also extremely proactive with communication and responsive. I’ll definitely stay here again!

We had a great time! Great place! Everything was easy!

Very relaxing cabin and quiet/quaint neighborhood. Even though you are in a neighborhood, you have privacy. We enjoyed the views and nature sounds. The private beaches are beautiful. Great place to relax. Cabin was cozy. The bed and bedding were sooooo comfy.

We had a great stay at Julia's place. It was exactly what was described and shown in the pictures. Beautiful and very quiet neighborhood. The home was older but you could only tell because of the original floors which had the charming creaks of original wood floors. Everything else has been upgraded and in great shape. Would be a great place anytime of year. Pool was closed obviously but the hot tub was perfect and the steam shower was nice. Only suggestion is that if you are arriving late definitely take a flashlight...it is very dark after the sun goes down. It was exactly what we needed. Julia was great with communication and available for anything we needed! Already have had discussions about coming back in the summer!

Carolyn’s home was amazing! My fiancé and I did a weekend getaway and felt so cozy in this home! It was private and clean and we really enjoyed it! Carolyn was very responsive to us and was considerate of us by checking in on if a snow plow would be needed since we went over a wintery weekend! Would love to come back again

The place was great! Quiet and serene (besides a few not too loud trains rolling through). Would definitely return. Thank you!

My husband and I had a wonderful winter getaway at Portia’s cabin! The place was exactly as described. We enjoyed exploring the collection of books and looking at all of the lovely art pieces throughout the cabin. We wanted to do some hiking at Grand Mere and Warren Dunes State Parks, so the proximity to these locations was perfect. We would love to stay there again!

Holley's place fit the description and photos exactly as presented. We were looking for a place that was relatively close to Notre Dame, and that allowed us to bring our dog. This place fit the bill. It was easy to find, clean, and as I said, fit the description and photos exactly. It was also a nice area to walk our dog. We were here in December and so we could not take advantage of the lake, but if you are here in summer, it's just a stone's throw away, and I imagine very nice. When you think about how much hotels in South Bend and even Elkhart charge on game days this was a no brainer. The price was solid and it was a relatively fast and easy drive from ND. I would definitely stay here again on another game weekend. Thank you Holley!

We loved Jesse’s cabin. It was very spacious and clean. It was also the perfect cabin for my dog with how much land there was.

We loved this cabin! Very quiet & peaceful. We felt like we were in the middle of nowhere but we were still close to several cute towns. Well stocked kitchen and bathrooms. We would absolutely stay here again!

We've been coming here for over 17 years. Great little cottage, picturesque setting with solid fishing. On this most recent trip, The Wailers (formed by Bob Marley) were playing at Warner Vineyards and we could hear that sweet reggae music while we BBQ'd and chilled by the campfire.

Excellent stay for a cabin get away. Peaceful. Amazing views. Cozy. Our highlights included 1) in home fireplace 2) excellent lighting throughout space 3) well decorated and maintained home 4) quiet area and neighborhood 5) location great between Michigan city and New Buffalo city centers.

Liz was an absolute wonderful host! We booked this Airbnb to celebrate our mom’s birthday and mine and my husband’s anniversary and it was PERFECT! We had access to plenty of water toys and kayaks! Every night we sat in the enclosed patio and enjoyed the views. Liz even left us fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, and peppers that we used to make a beautiful garden salad! We are vegetarians so it was truly a treat! We would definitely recommend this home to any family and we look forward to renting here again!

Our stay for the bachelor party was a great time and the vibes were immaculate during our stay!

Awesome cabin! It was wonderful for a Friendsgiving retreat - we even got to have a fire in the snow. Very grateful to Nina for being such a great host!

We loved everything about our weekend stay. Clean, peaceful and easy to enjoy. We would definitely stay again!

We loved staying at Darin’s place for our wedding anniversary. The pictures do not do this place justice. It was beautiful and relaxing. The willow tree shower was so cool! We had a blast and Darin is one of the nicest people we’ve ever met! Thank you so much for hosting us! We definitely would stay here again.

We had a very nice weekend at Lincoln Cottage. The common area is a really good idea. We enjoyed dinner out there as well as star gazing near fire pit. We were even approached by others interested in renting. We passed along card information. Host was very responsive to inquiries . Pictures do not do justice. Walking distance to lake . Short drive to South Haven. Plenty of room to spread out .

This place was a perfect getaway! Loved being close to the town of South Haven and then coming back to this place as a little escape. So peaceful and perfect for me, my husband and our baby. Definitely will be back!