Vacation rentals in Long Island

It was the first time my family and I visited Long Island. We met Docky and Jill and they made us feel at home from the very beginning. Starting from the simplest details of providing, coffee, tea, bug spray, baby oil for mosquitoes to the more complex like taking time out to direct us everywhere on the entire island. The home is equipped with all of the basics even some cooking seasonings. The yard is big and has a beautiful huge tamarind trees. a nice gazebo, grill and the house hilltop view was spectacular. We had true privacy and the neighbors were quiet and kept to themselves. We never saw them..You definitely will need a car to get around especially to restaurants and grocery shopping. It’s located to the very northern tip of the island. The busiest settlement is 45 minutes to the south. We will be back again and will be delighted to book with Bonafide fishing house again. We didn’t do any fishing with Docky because of the rain. We came as visitors and left feeling like locals.

The house and property: Peaceful. Pristine. Private. The host: Friendly. Knowledgeable. Responsive. Our family had a wonderful time at House Marlin! Cathy is a friendly, responsive, knowledgeable host. Check-in was easy. The house is clean and had all the amenities our family needed. We were steps from the beach and our kids loved the pool.

We had a truly wonderful time at Bill’s place. Bill met us at the house and gave us a tour . He is a very charming and knowledgeable host. The property is actually better than described and had everything that you could wish for. The house was spotless with very comfortable king size bed in the master bedroom and many lovely towels in the bathroom, which is a change from some of the Airbnbs we have stayed in previously. The views from the wrap around deck were stunning. We wholeheartedly recommend Bill’s place for anyone wishing to explore beautiful Long Island.

I stayed at this Airbnb for two nights and had a truly wonderful experience. The space was exactly as described—clean, peaceful, and well-equipped with everything I needed for day-to-day living, including kitchen supplies, toiletries, and comfortable furniture. The host was fantastic—very responsive, easy to communicate with, and genuinely accommodating. They made the entire process smooth and stress-free, which I really appreciated. The pricing was fair and completely matched what was listed—no surprises or extra charges. I felt that the value I received for the cost was excellent. Overall, this was one of the most seamless and comfortable Airbnb stays I’ve had. I would definitely love to stay here again in the future and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a well-managed and welcoming place to stay.

We stayed here for our anniversary trip and everything was awesome. Nice cool sea breeze. Beautiful sunrise and moon rise view. Quiet. Peaceful. Cozy. Check in n out was a breeze. They even decorated the place for valentines. We loved it.

We had a great stay here and would return 100%! PROS - Easy check-in and check-out. - Great location - Peaceful, close to the airport and other places, however you will need a car to get around. - Very clean and no clutter inside. Hot showers, lots of towels, large open plan areas. - All AC's worked great and we were all comfortable inside. - Location felt safe. CONS - Not really cons, more things to note. - There is a flight of stairs to enter the apartment. This didn't bother us at all but could be difficult for others to carry cases etc. up the stairs. - The kitchen didn't have power during our stay, however the host kindly offered us one that was just across the hallway which worked great for us. - The outside had great wildlife like money bats, lizards etc. however we did find a small scorpion in some clothes we left outside to dry. Again, this didn't bother us as it's nature and what we came to see! However we felt it was important to write this so others are aware.

The place was very clean and beautiful as in the Photos. The surroundings was so peaceful and quite which was really nice. Great location with stores right across the street, that we were able to pickup groceries and souvenirs. The host Monique was superb, she went above and beyond to make sure that our stay was a great one. She assisted us in finding a car rental, some great food and recommended the must visit spots of the island. We definitely will be recommending this location and host to our family and friends, who thinking about visiting Long Island.

My colleague and I enjoyed our stay. The ambiance was great and it was centrally located. The accommodation was spacious and we certainly felt safe. You will need a car rental to get around. The host and property management team on the ground were responsive and hospitable.