Vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

This is our go to Place while we are in town.

Belinda is an amazing host. Super quick responses. Kind and supportive. The condo was immaculate. The location and views are even better than the pictures shown in the listing.

This is a great place to stay - central to everything! Steve was incredibly responsive, there was plenty of sleeping space, the beds are comfortable, the kitchen is well-equipped, the house is very clean, and there's a great garage space to sit in during the summer. My only suggestion is if you are going in the winter and are a light sleeper, plan to use earplugs or a whitenoise app during the night because the furnace is a bit loud (it's in the hall closet, which is pretty common in this area). For what it's worth, my son isn't a light sleeper and it didn't bother him at all.

It was a very nice place. It was easy to find and very clean. The only issue we had was with the washer and dryer. The washer did not spin out effectively and we had to hand wring the towels before we put them in the dryer. Also the lint filter on the dryer was dirty when we got there and had to be cleaned before we could use it . Overall it was a good place to stay.

This rental was exceptionally clean and very convenient to Cedar Point. There was plenty of room for our family of 5. Brandon and Kimberly were very helpful and quick to respond to an issue we had. We would absolutely stay here again!

A great 3rd floor lookout over the marinas, though frozen at the moment. A modern, clean comfortable unit. Couldn't have been happier. Tim was friendly, helpful and easy to reach. Thanks for a great stay.

I’d definitely recommend and give Chelsea’s river rental 5 stars! My family and I were in town for a weekend trip to the Erie Islands. Best choice we made to stay in this very cozy air b&b directly above a local bakery across the street from the Portage river. Amazing coffee shop and grocery store in walking distance. Very clean and comfortable with charm. We will definitely be back to stay again.

We met up with family to stay on the lake for several days, and it was just perfect. We had 8 adult sized folks, and we fit in just perfectly. The location is just amazing...right on the lake with access to swimming and kayaks. The place felt more roomy than the pictures...there is a really nice sitting room where most of us could sit, plus two screened in porches and plenty of seating outside. Kitchen is extremely well stocked. Central air was key for us and provided a nice respite from the heat. We drove 30 minutes to Cedar Point, and it was close enough that we came home for a few hours to take a break from the heat and went back for the evening. Hosts were just super on it, proactive, and very helpful. Highly recommend. Oh and the outdoor shower really was a highlight. Sounds silly, but we all loved it!