Cottage vacation rentals in Ithaca

We really enjoyed our time at Randall’s lake house! It has a beautiful view of the lake and is an easy drive to downtown Ithaca. Randall was very responsive and provided very clear instructions. Highly recommend!

A lovely, cozy cottage perfect for a couple’s getaway. Homey decor, very comfortable bed, decent water pressure and a wonderful little kitchen with pans and utensils needed for home cooked meals. We had a wonderful time feeling at home and comfortable here. The host is friendly and responsive and gave very easy and clear instructions for arrival and departure. Would definitely stay here again.

Had a great time at the Finger Lakes! Terrific location for exploring wineries on the three surrounding lakes. House was very well equipped, hot tub felt wonderful in the evening after exploring during the chilly days, and such a relaxing and serene setting right on the lake. Host was very quick to respond to any questions. This will definitely be a choice for future trips.

Location, location, location! Right on the water, hot tub was great, comfortable place and it was just perfect for us. We loved the local wineries and other activities and it was so nice to come back to that beautiful lake view at the end of the day. Thanks so much Nick and Chrissy! We would love to come back one day.

We had a great time at Diane's place. Diane and Tom gave us a warm welcome and were very responsive and communicative before and during our stay. They also had plenty of recommendations on things to do. The hot tub was a major plus! Overall, would highly recommend if you're planning to stay in the area. We primarily went to visit Watkins Glen, which was just about 20 minutes away.

Really cool spot, enjoyed the walk to the lake and the hot tub. Would definitely recommend and hope to stay there again

Perfect spot for a girls weekend! Peaceful and adorable home on a beautiful scenic lake, centrally-located to the wineries and restaurants around Keuka Lake. Thanks for hosting us!

We have stayed at this house multiple times. It is our home away from home at the Finger Lakes. You can’t beat the location! The house is absolutely perfect. It is a wonderful getaway. I can’t recommend it enough.

We had our annual girls weekend up in the Finger Lakes. This was a perfect location for us to visit a plethora of wineries, enjoy the lake, and go on a hike. The home was cozy and it was a great place to end our nights at. Mary was a great host and super communicative - gave us some great tips about wineries and some other local spots. Thank you for making this trip a wonderful one!

We had a lovely time on our trip. One of the highlights was being able to stay in such a cozy, well decorated home. Everything felt comfortable and we really appreciated the proactive effort from our host in reaching out to see if we needed anything. This was a wonderful trip, we're looking forward to booking again sometime in the future!

Our stay in Lodi was amazing. Beautiful view of the lake while watching tv, cooking or just playing a game. Very Peaceful. Easy to walk our dog. Love how the bedrooms are on each side of the house as well as bathrooms as to not disturb one another... beautiful.. many wineries and breweries for tastings, & most are Dog friendly too! So easy to sit back and relax! My daughter & boyfriend loved hiking and also did some golf! This was a Beautiful getaway and the host was so great and attentive. So clean and so comfy.

Michele and Andy were friendly, helpful, hospitable hosts, and their farm is beautiful! We enjoyed a relaxing weekend surrounded by their horses, cows, fields and forests. The house itself has rustic, unpolished, handmade charm and is decorated very tastefully. The bed was comfortable, the wood stove was easy to use and helped us stay warm for our winter visit. Michele was accommodating of our arrival and departure times, going out of her way to try to help us adjust plans to match the weather. She was also very helpful in providing restaurant recommendations and information about the area. We highly recommend staying here!

Thank you for letting us stay at your lovely house! We had the best time. The location is perfect, the house was so clean and the view was stunning. We highly recommend this lovely lake house!

We loved our stay! The house was awesome, very comfortable, and had everything we might need during our stay. Those rocking chairs on the porch were the icing on the cake. So lovely - hope to come again during the summer or fall.

This was our third time staying here while visiting family and we had a great stay! Our dog loved running in the fenced in yard, and our daughter loved watching from the deck. Always great hosts and a very easy stay!

The Little House is in a perfect location, near scenic trails and some of the best restaurants, wineries, and breweries in the area. Communication with Hannah and Dustin was great, and they recommended some local spots and even places in another nearby town we were staying in the night before checking in.

We had a great stay at the lake cottage. The view is stunning. The barbecue is a real plus!

This cabin is the perfect place to switch off from the world and relax. The lake is beautiful. The cabin is clean and well equipped. James and Renee are lovely people whose main aim is for people to enjoy the experience of staying at their properties. Jamie brought us fish from the river and kitted us out with bikes to save us hiring some. A lovely stay.

We had an incredible time at Jesse and Bernadette’s!! 10/10 would stay here the next time we visit the Finger Lakes. Truly magical. Falling asleep to the sound of the lake was a definite highlight.

Such a beautiful place! Mary and Mark have a lovely home and the inside was super clean and exactly as described. The location was great and Mary provided a list of amazing local recommendations. They were so quick to respond and very kind. Highly recommend and will definitely be back!

We loved our stay at the lake! The views were beautiful, the cabin was peaceful, and everything felt right at home. Wish we could have stayed longer!

Wow - what a fantastic lakeside retreat! There must be 6 different places to sit/gather outside - the fire table was especially nice for sipping some Riesling on a chilly night. Well equipped kitchen, and lots of amenities (including kayaks if so inclined). Very quiet surroundings (we were there during the week-end, too), but you have to watch out for the seagulls - they like to hang out on the deck. Great location is within 1/2 hour of many excellent wineries and restaurants. Would definitely return here the next time we are in FLX!

Wonderful place to stay for our family of four! Beautiful view and clean, cozy home with all amenities needed to feel at home. We look forward to the next time we have the chance to make it to the upstate NY area and stay here again!

No frills, but exactly what you need for a relaxing stay on the lake in FLX. Cabin is well equipped for whatever weather you encounter- plenty of fans, heaters, blankets, and windows. There are many lighting options, portable lamps, and tons of outlets. There are 2 wineries walking distance from the property, and dozens of wineries, breweries, cideries, restaurants, stores and more within a 20 minute drive. Just a little further gets you to Geneva, Ithaca, Watkins Glen and more- the scenery can't be beat. It is incredibly dark and quiet around the property, so rain, wind, falling branches, etc. can seem a bit alarming, but just know that going in and don't let it deter you! Bruce was available for check-in and checked-in to make sure everything was going well. I would definitely return!