House vacation rentals in Honeoye Lake

We had an amazing stay. Traci was very accommodating. The home was as expected. I can’t say enough how happy I was with our stay. And each room had a sound machine that we all found helpful. I even ordered one for myself! I’ll be definitely staying again !

The house was conveniently laid out for our family group. The beds were very comfortable and everything was super clean. We had a 10 month old with us so the high chair and crib were much appreciated. Door Dash found the house easily too

I loved this place so much! We are definitely going back at some point in the summer for that pool! But everything was perfect and everyone had a great time! The house was so cozy but huge! It felt like we’ve been there forever when we got there, the hot tub was so relaxing especially with the view! I love this place and the driveway isn’t that bad but you will definitely need 4WD! It’s like a fun slow roller coaster lol😂! We also saw a group of turkeys every morning and they were so cute!

A really wonderful find just outside of Rochester (around 2 hours away from Ithaca, Niagara Falls, Buffalo, or the NYS Fair). The house and pool were wonderful, with really comfortable beds, a large living room, a full kitchen, and a great backyard. Sergey was wonderful from start to finish. He made sure the pool was cleaned every morning, answered all of our questions, and was just overall very friendly. Our group of 6 felt right at home. Would love to return at some point in the future!

5/5 – A Perfect Family Getaway We had an incredible stay and truly didn’t want to leave. The home was ideal for a family vacation—comfortable, well-equipped, and full of thoughtful touches. My children were devastated to go! We had planned a few small adventures in the surrounding area, but they were so happy in the pool that we barely left the property. We came during spring break from upstate New York, where it was still snowing, so the warm weather and sunshine were a much-needed reprieve. The house had everything we needed: Netflix, Alexa, a garage full of pool noodles and floaties, and a lovely selection of children’s books that my toddlers adored. One of the most heartwarming moments was when Neil kindly gifted my daughter a stuffed cat she had fallen in love with—it meant so much to her and to us. This was the kind of stay that creates lasting memories. We can’t wait to come back.

Great peaceful place to stay while seeing local friends. Comfy inside, garage parking was an awesome plus and our dog absolutely loved the large open yard behind the guest house. The host was super friendly and responsive to any questions we had. Was exactly what we needed for our weekend!

We had a wonderful time staying at this cozy lake cottage! It was perfect for our party of 9 and we would definitely stay again! Highly recommend!

Our stay was fantastic! Rebecca was an awesome host, and so easy to communicate with. Highly, highly recommend if you’re looking for a beautiful getaway.

We stayed only one night for New Year's eve. We had a lovely time. Beautiful view on the lake. The house is charming! Plenty of space. We would have stayed longer.. Derrick responded quickly to our queries. All was perfect! Thank you.

Our stay on the lake was wonderful. The housing was perfect and met our needs. This would be a great house to rent during the summer months. WE had a little trouble locating the house initially as it is located among other houses and the drive down to the house is not clearly marked. If you are coming from the south you need to make a turn almost opposite the way you are coming into a steep drive to the housing. It needs to be better marked, maybe with an arrow and house number. The house could also us a little address sign on the walkway for clarification. HOWEVER, the stay was great and getting information to the person in charge was easy. The accommodations were very good. The view was wonderful. The water frontage is a bit steep but there are steps to bring you to the water. In all this is a wonderful home for vacation with amenities about 15 minutes away. I would give Nancy or Eric a call again.

Eric’s place was great! We had everything we needed for our week long stay! The house was also VERY clean. This may sound silly, but I’ve stayed in many vacation homes, and you can always tell how clean a place is by the small details, like coffee maker, drawers, etc…I was so pleased to find that the coffee pot and filter had been run through the dishwasher before we arrived! the kitchen was spotless and well stocked. It’s the small things, that really make a difference in your comfort level! Eric was also very accommodating and responsive to a special request we had! This is a great house, and we would definitely stay again!

What a beautiful and peaceful home! We loved spending time in the hot tub, playing games, and enjoying the fire. Only downside was low water pressure in the primary bathroom shower, but not a huge issue. Galina was incredibly responsive and helpful. We loved our stay!

Beautiful property in a beautiful, quiet neighborhood. This place was perfect for our family of 5 children. Becca quickly responded to questions. I would definitely stay here again.

As described- nice place on the water great for a nice quiet getaway. I would definitely go back. Amenities are super close by and the grill and fire pit are huge adds for an awesome weekend. Some parts of the house are starting to show age a bit and some simple upgrades like bathroom doorknobs could go a long way, but the place is definitely charming and quaint!

Our family thoroughly enjoyed this house. It was extremely comfortable with everything we needed. We loved taking the kayaks out, the views were absolutely breathtaking. A very beautiful and peaceful location!

Our two day stay was great, especially since we could bring our two dogs! The house was amazing and the furnishings were perfect! The space felt so much larger than we thought. It was amazingly clean and well organized.

We were so grateful to stay here during our visit to Palmyra. The location is close to everything and easily accessible. Thank you!

We stayed a week with another family. The location is great for several reasons including walkable to restaurants, wineries, breweries, hiking and other small shops. We chose it mainly for its central location to large state parks like Letchworth and Watkins Glen although there was a great hike just down the street. The home was clean, neat, updated and well appointed. Keypad entry was good for easy access. Nice touches inside and out that made it homey like decorative lights on the deck, books on the shelves, artwork on the walls. The unique layout also allowed each family some privacy. Homeowner was a pleasure to interact with, very responsive to questions and had helpful advice for the area. We very much enjoyed our stay!

It was a wonderful experience staying at Larry and Don’s place. The house is so cozy, perfectly equipped, and very clean. The view of the lake from the windows is calming and adds to the uniqueness of the home. Larry and Don were fully available, and everything we hoped for was exactly as expected. We were four adults and four children, and we had plenty of space — it never felt crowded. We highly recommend staying with Larry and Don!

I can't say enough about Meg's lovely home. It accommodated six adults and a child in extremely comfortable surroundings. The kitchen is equipped with everything you need (and I covet her backsplash and pot-filler). We could all easily fit around the dining room table. The back deck is ideal for relaxing in a gorgeous surrounding. We all commented how beautiful the area is. Meg is extremely responsive, accessible and pro-active. It's a five-star stay! I rank it among our best AirBnB experiences.

Lovely weekend getaway. Cozy stay inside and outside. Visited our favorite wineries. Nice quiet walks. Rained a lot but that didn’t matter with wood burning stove inside. His house offers everything to able to just bring yourself, clothes and food.

I had a wonderful 3-night stay at this cozy cabin. The location was perfect for a peaceful getaway, surrounded by nature. The cabin itself was clean, well-equipped, and had a charming rustic feel. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a great spot close to Watkins Glen and area!

Cute little place. Right on the water as advertised. Cozy, not a lot to take care of while you’re there. Plenty of utensils, very clear instructions comfortable.

We had a great stay over Christmas! There was plenty of room for my family of 5. It was exactly as described. Very homey and comfortable. Had a little blip with the wifi, but Chris responded right away and sent someone out to help. I appreciated the wine and coffee that was gifted to us from the host, it was a nice touch, especially during the holidays. I would recommend this place for anyone's stay in the area. I will definitely check to see if this place is available for future stays back home :)