Cabin vacation rentals in Buckeye Lake

Cindy is such a wonderful person and host who truly cares for the families staying at her cabin! This cabin was perfect! It was comfy, clean, and so well taken care of. We truly appreciate it! Definitely choose this cabin for your next getaway! We had no complaints! 🥰

We enjoyed our stay as a multi-family group. Bedrooms set up with space for everyone and gathering spaces for the day. Fully stocked kitchen for large meals enjoyed together. Thank you for sharing with us and suggestions of places to visit.

We made life long memories this weekend in Greg’s absolutely beautiful cabin. We loved the indoor pool so much! It was a typical, chilly Ohio April and truly made the vacation to have our own private pool with heated floors. Everyone was so nice and helpful. Would recommend!

Was a beautiful stay! Exactly what my family neede to heal! Will definitely stay again!

We enjoyed our stay here at the end of March 2025. It was mostly quite. The hot tub was nice and the place was clean. We had our coffee on the huge front porch in the morning. A young gray and white cat loved to hang out. I named him Oscar 😀 We found a nice little bakery about 10 minutes away in Millersport as well as some nice little hometown restaurants. We took a stroll down by the lake which is literally a 3 minute walk from the cabin.

Amazing place, will come back!!!

Home is beautiful and great size. Had everything we needed.

This home hosted our family thanksgiving as well as a 90th birthday celebration. We felt right at home in the cozy yet spacious cabin. We were able to do nature walks, the kids had a great time in the game room, and it felt homie. Kim was so responsive, was kind enough to let us check in early, and even return to collect forgotten items. A great space to spend quality time with friends and family. We can’t wait to come back!

Such a charming cabin, in an awesome location. The neighborhood is quiet, and close to everything we needed during our stay. The beds were comfortable, the cabin was clean. The host was helpful and responsive. Can’t wait to stay again!!

Was an amazing get away. She was very polite and helpful with any question I had

I had an amazing stay at Gina's cabin in the countryside! The location is incredibly peaceful, and the cabin itself is cozy and spacious. One of the highlights was the beautiful hangar nearby perfect if you're into flying. The stars at night were so bright and magnificent. I got stuck in a mud pit in Gina's driveway when I arrived, but Gina’s husband and son were incredibly kind and helpful, quickly coming to help. Gina also invited us to walk around her beautiful farm, where we got to see some cute goats and cows The cabin is very well-equipped. I asked Gina if I could borrow a stove to cook, and she provided a double hot plate, which worked perfectly for the meals we prepared. The toaster oven is large enough to bake a whole chicken, which was a wonderful surprise! If you don't mind ladybugs occasionally crawling in your bedroom, this place is absolutely perfect. Overall, it was a peaceful and relaxing retreat, and I highly recommend it!

This stay was absolutely beautiful! The balcony overlooked grazing sheep and the cabin was clean and homey! Exactly what we were looking for!

Kelly’s listing is better than we hoped for and for a very fair price. We were lucky to reserve it for us last minute. We were traveling with a newborn and their tiny home was truly a blessing. Perfectly sound and private. You can tell they put a lot of work into the place! Thank you Kelly!

This is a great getaway spot! It is very quiet and peaceful. Autumn was very nice, and the check in process was easy. The place itself is very comfortable and has everything you need. And of course the property is amazing, with lots to explore. I would definitely like to stay again, and will recommend it to others!

the cabin with the lofts was quite a great experience. we booked last minute and found it easy to get in touch with Mark, check in, and check out hassle free. i wish there were some more photos of the place, but generally we found it well stocked with items for a rustic off-grid cabin. there were 2 bathroom facilities - an outhouse and a port a potty. the loft sleeping area had 2 queen mattresses with pillows and blankets. the kitchen was stocked with 2 camping stoves. the whole place was heated by propane and we got so toasty, we turned it off at night. Dillon State Park is a 15m drive from the place, but it feels private and serene. save headlamps and some metal cutlery, the cabin had everything we needed! definitely want to return here some day.

One of the most unique places I have ever stayed. The design, craftsmanship and material selection of the home give it a sturdy yet storybook feel. From the driveway to house you are transported into Froto's shire.

this isn't our first time at this cute little cabin and hopefully it's not our last. it's nice and tucked away but close enough to town.

It was wonderful!! The house filled our needs/wants, the location was perfect, and the hiking was a piece of heaven!

If it were possible, I would give it a rating of 100. Everything was so wonderful that we immediately planned when we could come back again! Special thanks to the farm owners, I was honored to meet wonderful and kind people. They did everything they could to make sure we had fond memories!

Host was very helpful in answering our questions. The house was cozy and clean. We loved our stay.

This was the second time we have stayed at the Unique Kabin. We think it's the coolest. This year it rained the whole time we were there, to hear the rain on the tin roof and the creek flowing, it made for a very relaxing weekend. We will be staying again. Its our favorite!