Boutique hotel vacation rentals in Lake Montauk

Find and book unique boutique hotels on Airbnb

Top-rated boutique hotels in Lake Montauk

Guests agree: these boutique hotel rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

Hotel room in Old Lyme

Spectacular Master Suite in Historic Mansion

Enjoy a luxurious experience when you stay in the Master Suite at Ludington House. Ascend the Grand Staircase to the second floor to find the showpiece of the nine bedroom mansion. The private suite features His and Hers Bathrooms/Dressing Room and a four post King Bed. Outside your suite you have use of the "morning room"; a charming light-filled living area filled with local art and literature that is shared with one other guestroom. The adjoining foyer has a small kitchenette for beverages.

Superhost

Hotel room in Newport

2 Queen Beds - America's Cup Inn

2 Queen Bedroom with private bathroom overlooking Thames St. This is a very charming room in the heart of Newport Downtown. You'll be a few steps from pubs like Brick Alley Pub & right across the street from Irish Pub, few steps from restaurants like The Mooring, The Black Pear, 22 Bowen's and more, you choose! Close to bars, arcade, ice cream & the Newport Shipyard. Walk 2 minutes and you'll be at the Perrotti Park waiting for the ferry tours around the Island. Second floor room, no elevator.

Guest favourite

Hotel room in mystic

Downtown Mystic Suite with fireplace, king, futon

Located in the heart of downtown Mystic in the Historic District, this charming suite offers everything you need for a relaxing stay. This 600 sq ft suite has a king bed, futon, fireplace, kitchenette and private bath. There is a beautiful brick terrace and gardens behind the Carriage House with a fire pit, bbq, and plenty of seating. Leave you car behind as everything Mystic has to offer is just a short 3 minute walk. There is off street parking as well.

Superhost

Hotel room in Aquebogue

Aqua - Deluxe King Water View - Adults Only

Located in the heart of Long Island’s wine country, Aqua by American Beech is just 1 ½ hours from Manhattan and within 3 miles from winery area. You can find more than 50 wineries to enjoy and guests are in close proximity to all Hamptons and North Fork villages and enjoy priority reservations at the American Beech Restaurant in Greenport. Pet fee $110 The guest has to pay taxes and resort fee, $35 per night at the check in. Check in starts at 4pm

Hotel room in Montauk

Two Bedroom Apartment - Kenny's Tipperary Inn

Welcome to our charming two-bedroom apartment at a boutique hotel, perfect for couples & families. Enjoy a cozy living room, a full kitchen, private bedroom and bathroom. The inn's amenities: outdoor pool, BBQ, fire pit, outdoor seating areas. Max capacity is 6 (including children). ***Each unit is individually decorated. Exact unit may not be depicted. All have equal amenities, but decor and finishes vary.***

Guest favourite

Hotel room in Newport

Studio @ Pelham Court Special pricing available

Our units are finished to the highest of standards. Each condominium offers spacious living areas and fully equipped stainless steel kitchens with beautiful granite countertops. Each room is equipped with Smart TV's for use of Netflix, Prime, Hulu and others. We are steps from Thames Street and Broadway. You are able to park your vehicle for free and never have to drive again until you check out.

Guest favourite

Hotel room in Newport

Newport Boutique Hotel Queen Bed w/Parking

Located in the Marshall Slocum Inn, the Snuggery is a small room featuring a queen bed and a spiral staircase within the room that goes up to a private bathroom with shower. Onsite parking, WiFi incl. As of November 8th, 2020 we will not be offering breakfast but will rather have a to go cafe for guests to purchase breakfast, lunch and appetizer items.